ἀγεωμέτρητος μηδεὶς εἰσίτω

Simulation Theory

Modern Simulation Theory Daddy Nick Bostrom is a Swedish philosopher who spent most of his career at Oxford, where he founded and led the Future of Humanity Institute until it closed in 2024. He focuses on big existential questions, like the risks of advanced AI.

His paper “Are You Living in a Computer Simulation?” was published in Philosophical Quarterly in 2003. It’s about 13 pages and free on Bostrom’s site, simulation-argument.com. It’s very readable, mostly plain English with one simple formula:

Fraction of simulated people =

(f × N) ÷ (f × N + 1)

  • f = the fraction of civilizations that reach the high-tech stage
  • N = how many simulations each of those civilizations runs

If f × N is large, the answer gets really close to 1, meaning almost everyone is simulated. For example, if 1% of civilizations make it and each runs 1,000 simulations, f × N = 10, so about 91% of all people are simulated.

Simulation Theory (or hypothesis), is the proposal that everything we experience in our everyday reality including our planet, our physical bodies, and the universe is an artificial, high-tech computer simulation.

Like in the Matrix?

In The Matrix you’re a real person. Your body is lying in a pod, and machines plug your brain into a fake world. Taking the red pill means waking up in your actual body.

In Bostrom’s version: there’s no body anywhere. You are the code. There’s nothing to wake up to. (How devastating).

So The Matrix is closer to “brain in a vat” than true simulation theory.

Why is this a thing?

The Speed of Light: Serving as an absolute speed limit in the universe, it mimics the maximum processing or rendering speed of a computer system loading data.

Quantum Mechanics: Subatomic particles exist in multiple probability states until they are observed or measured, resembling how video games only render environments when a player looks at them to save memory.

Pixels of Reality: Concepts like the Planck length (the smallest possible measurement of space) could act like pixels or a fundamental resolution limit for our universe.

Is this a new idea?

No. People have always suspected a deeper, hidden truth. In Hinduism, the concept of Maya holds that the world is an illusion, a veil over the true reality, Brahman. Buddhism teaches that the separate self is an illusion, and the Diamond Sutra compares all of existence to a dream, a bubble, and a flash of lightning. In China, Zhuangzi dreamed he was a butterfly, then woke up unsure whether he was a man who’d dreamed of being a butterfly or a butterfly now dreaming he was a man. In Greece, Plato described prisoners in a cave mistaking shadows on a wall for the real world. The Gnostics believed a lesser god built the material world as a prison to keep our souls from remembering where they came from. Descartes wondered if an evil demon was faking everything he experienced. 

Ripples of Simulation Theory

Hinduism

(c. 800–200 BC)

Hinduism, one of the oldest living religions, has been asking whether this world is the real thing for at least 3,000 years. In the Upanishads, ancient sacred texts written in India between roughly 800 and 200 BC, the ultimate reality is Brahman: one infinite, eternal consciousness behind everything that exists. What we experience instead is Maya, a veil of illusion that makes the one appear as many: separate people, separate objects, a separate “you.” Around the 8th century AD, the philosopher Adi Shankara sharpened this into the school of Advaita Vedanta, teaching that your true self, Atman, was never separate from Brahman at all. You just forgot. Hinduism even has a word for why the illusion exists: Lila, divine play, the universe as a game consciousness plays with itself. Swap Maya for code and Brahman for whatever is running the program, and you have simulation theory, with one crucial twist: the player and the programmer are the same being, playing hide and seek with itself.

Buddhism

(5th century BC)

Around the 5th century BC in northern India, a prince named Siddhartha Gautama left his palace to find the cause of human suffering, and after years of searching, he sat beneath a tree and woke up. That’s what Buddha means: “the awakened one.” What he woke up from was the belief that the world, and the self, are solid and separate. Buddhism teaches anatta, no-self: the “you” you think you are is a constantly shifting stream of thoughts, sensations, and memories with no fixed core underneath. Everything is impermanent, arising and dissolving moment to moment. We’re caught in samsara, an endless cycle of birth, death, and rebirth, driven by mistaking the illusion for the real thing. The Diamond Sutra, a Buddhist text whose oldest surviving copy from 868 AD is the world’s oldest dated printed book, compares everything we experience to a dream, a bubble, a shadow, and a flash of lightning.  There’s no real world to escape to, no body waiting in a pod. Awakening doesn’t take you out of the game; it’s realizing you’re dreaming while you’re still in the dream. 

Plato’s Cave

(c. 375 BC)

Around 375 BC in Athens, Greece, Plato wrote The Republic, a dialogue in which his teacher Socrates sets out to answer one question: what is justice? Along the way, in Book VII, Socrates tells a story. Prisoners are chained inside a cave their whole lives, facing a blank wall. Behind them, a fire burns, and objects carried past it cast shadows on the wall. Since the shadows are all they’ve ever seen, the prisoners believe the shadows are reality. When one prisoner breaks free, he discovers the fire, then the world outside, and finally the sun, and realizes everything he knew was only a projection of something more real. When he returns to tell the others, they don’t believe him. Swap the cave wall for a screen and the fire for a computer, and you have simulation theory, written 2,400 years before Bostrom. Plato’s question is the same one we’re still asking: what if what we experience is a rendering of reality, not the real thing, and what would it take to turn around and see the source?

Zhuangzi’s Butterfly Dream

(c. 300 BC)

Around 300 BC, during China’s Warring States period, a time of constant war between rival kingdoms, a Daoist philosopher named Zhuangzi fell asleep and dreamed he was a butterfly. He fluttered around happily, completely unaware he had ever been anything else. Then he woke up, solid and unmistakably Zhuangzi. But he couldn’t shake the question: was he a man who had dreamed he was a butterfly, or a butterfly now dreaming he was a man? The story appears in a chapter of his book titled The Equality of Things, and he ends it by calling this “the transformation of things,” the idea that forms flow into one another, and the boundaries we draw between them aren’t as fixed as we think. Living around the same time as Plato, on the other side of the world, Zhuangzi landed on the same problem as simulation theory: from inside an experience, you can’t prove it’s the real one. The butterfly felt just as real as the man.

The Gnostics

(1st–3rd century AD)

In the first few centuries after Jesus, across Egypt, Syria, and Rome, groups of early Christian mystics known as the Gnostics, from the Greek gnosis, meaning “knowledge,” developed one of the darkest takes on reality ever written. They believed the true God was pure spirit, infinite and unknowable, and had nothing to do with creating this world. Instead, the physical universe was built by a lesser, flawed being called the Demiurge, who either didn’t know or didn’t care that something greater existed beyond him. He was assisted by rulers called Archons, whose job was to keep human souls trapped in the material world, distracted and asleep. But inside each person was a divine spark, a piece of the true God, and salvation didn’t come from faith or good behavior. It came from gnosis: direct, personal knowledge of who you really are. For centuries, most of their writings were lost, destroyed as heresy by the early Church, until 1945, when a farmer in Nag Hammadi, Egypt, dug up a sealed jar containing dozens of Gnostic texts. Swap the Demiurge for the Architect and the Archons for the Agents, and you have The Matrix. Of all the ancient traditions, the Gnostics come closest to the movie’s version: the world is a prison built by someone who isn’t the real creator, and the red pill is remembering where you came from.

Descartes

(1641)

In 1641, during the Scientific Revolution, the French philosopher and mathematician René Descartes, the man who invented the x and y graph you learned in school, published Meditations on First Philosophy. He wanted to find one thing he could know with absolute certainty, so he decided to doubt everything. His senses had fooled him before, so they couldn’t be trusted. He’d had dreams that felt completely real, so how could he know he wasn’t dreaming now? Then he pushed it to the extreme: what if a powerful, evil demon was deliberately deceiving him, faking the sky, the earth, his own body, even the math in his head? Every single thing he experienced could be manufactured. But one thing survived: even if he was being fooled, someone had to be there being fooled. This led to the most famous line in philosophy: I think, therefore I am. Swap the demon for a computer, and you have simulation theory, nearly 400 years early. But Descartes’s twist is the one that matters most: the simulation can fake everything you experience, except the one experiencing it. The world might be code. Consciousness is the only thing that can’t be.

Philip K. Dick

(1977)

Philip K. Dick, the American science fiction writer born in 1928, spent his whole career asking one question: what’s real? His stories became Blade Runner, Total Recall, Minority Report, A Scanner Darkly, and The Man in the High Castle, and almost all of them involve fake memories, fake worlds, or people who aren’t sure if they’re even human. Then, in 1974, it stopped being fiction. Dick said a beam of pink light hit him and downloaded information straight into his mind, including a warning that his infant son had an undiagnosed hernia. He took his son to the doctor, who confirmed it, and the boy had surgery. Dick spent the rest of his life trying to make sense of what happened, filling thousands of handwritten pages later published as The Exegesis, drawing heavily on the Gnostics to explain it. In 1977, at a science fiction convention in Metz, France, he stood in front of a crowd and told them we live in a computer-programmed reality, and that the only clue we get is when a variable is changed and something in our world shifts, like a moment of déjà vu. Twenty-two years later, The Matrix used that exact idea: déjà vu is a glitch, a sign that someone changed the code. Dick died in 1982, just months before Blade Runner hit theaters. He was 26 years ahead of Bostrom, and he didn’t need math to get there. He said he’d seen it.

Quantum Physics

(1900s–1989)

In the early 1900s, physicists trying to understand the tiniest building blocks of the universe discovered that reality doesn’t behave the way it looks. In the famous double-slit experiment, particles like electrons are fired at a barrier with two openings. When no one measures which slit they go through, they act like waves, spreading out and passing through both at once, leaving a pattern only waves can make. But the moment you measure their path, they snap into acting like solid particles, picking one slit. Until it’s measured, a particle doesn’t seem to have a definite location at all, just a cloud of possibilities. To simulation theorists, this looks a lot like a video game, which only renders what the player is looking at to save processing power. Other clues seem to fit: the universe has a smallest possible unit of length, the Planck length, like a pixel, and a maximum speed, the speed of light, like a processor’s limit. In 1989, physicist John Wheeler summed up his view of reality in three words: “it from bit,” the idea that everything physical arises from information. Most physicists say “measurement” means any interaction with the environment, not a conscious observer. But a few, going back to John von Neumann and Eugene Wigner, argued that consciousness itself is what collapses the wave, and that question has never been settled. And if they were right, the simulation isn’t rendering for a computer. It’s rendering for you.

What are you looking 404?